|
||||||||||||
|
||||||||||||
Taylor is calling for Ottawa to commence trade action through the World Trade Organization should the European legislation be adopted. "It's time for the rubber to hit the road." Federal Fisheries Minister Loyola Hearn issued a statement saying Ottawa supports Canada's sealing industry and discussions will soon start with the Europeans to map out exemptions to the proposed legislation. "Once again, we would like to caution European decision-makers: Adopting broad regulations to ban products from a responsible, sustainable and well-regulated hunt is a slippery slope. To bow to misinformation and emotional rhetoric in restricting the trade of humanely harvested animals would set a dangerous precedent for all wild hunts," Hearn said. Touring Europe to make Canada's case for the seal hunt, Canadian fisheries ambassador Loyola Sullivan said he expected a "very lengthy process" to follow yesterday's announcement - one that could include a visit by EU parliamentarians to Canada this fall - before a ban comes into effect. Animal rights groups applauded Europe's move but say it falls short since it allows exemptions for products obtained from hunts that can show seals did not suffer unnecessarily. © The Gazette (Montreal) 2008
Brussels plans to ban seal tradingBy Nikki Tait in Brussels Published: July 24 2008 06:20 | Last updated: July 24 2008 06:20 Brussels on Wednesday proposed to outlaw trading in seal products which breach animal welfare standards. The move brought cheers from animal rights campaigners but risks triggering tensions with Canada. The European Commission’s proposal would ban the import into the EU of products that came from seals that had been killed in an unnecessarily painful way. A similar ban would also be placed on the transiting of such products through the European bloc and on exports from the EU. “Seal products coming from countries which practice cruel hunting methods must not be allowed to enter the EU,” said EU enviroment commissioner Stavros Dimas on Wednesday. “The EU is committed to upholding high standards of animal welfare.” The commission said that scientists at the European Food Safety Authority believed that seals could be killed rapidly and efficiently, but that effective killing does not always take place in practice. There have been concerns, for example, that seals are sometimes struck and then lost, resulting in suffering, and also that skinning may take place while animals remain concious. On Wednesday night, Loyola Hearn, Canadian fisheries minister, said the country would be “reviewing how the proposed regulations and any exemptions would apply to Canada”. “Canada expects the EU to quickly begin discussions on the conditions for exemption from the draft regulations so that any any trade restriction would have no impact on market access for products from Canada’s humane regulated and responsible hunt”, he said. “We will continue to stand up for sealers to protect the Canadian sealing industry and our markets”. On Wednesday, EU officials said a certification scheme would be established in countries where seal-hunting continued. This might also be accompanied by a labelling system to ensure that seal products that were traded were clearly identified as coming from countries meeting strict conditions. The commission’s move was welcomed by animal rights campaigners, but many called for a more comprehensive ban. “European citizens demand a total ban on seal product trade. It is essential that the EU ends its trade in all products derived from commercial seal hunts,” said Mark Glover, at the Humane Society International. “The people of Europe and the European Parliament will accept nothing less than a total ban,” said Neil Parish, a UK Conservative MEP who is president of the Euopean Parliament’s animal welfare group. However, the move may trigger problems with Canada which exports over C$5m-worth of seal products to the EU annually. It has already said that public pressure to curtail the seal product trade in Europe has been driven by misinformation from anti-sealing organisations and claimed that its own hunts are humane and sustainable. Canada also lodged a complaint with the World Trade Organisation over Dutch and Belgian bans on seal products last year. Copyright The Financial Times Limited 2008
Seal hunt reeling from EU proposed banBY TARA BRAUTIGAM Last updated at 11:10 PM on 23/07/08 ST. JOHN’S, N.L. — The future of Canada’s commercial harp seal hunt, a centuries-old industry and way of life for several thousand East Coast fishermen, was thrown into question Wednesday after the European Union proposed a partial ban of seal products. Countries that “practice cruel hunting methods” would not be allowed to send seal products to the 27-nation bloc under legislation proposed by EU Environment Commissioner Stavros Dimas. “The images of seal hunting that circulate around the globe every year are a reminder of the oftentimes gruesome practices used to kill seals,” Dimas told a news conference in Brussels. “European citizens find this practice is repugnant and in contradiction to our standards of animal welfare.” The proposed ban needs the support of the EU’s 27 governments and the European Parliament before it can take effect. Jack Troake, who has hunted seals off the coast of Twillingate, N.L., since 1951, said he was not surprised by the move, but was disappointed nonetheless. “All of this gallivanting around back and forth from Canada to Europe, discussing and debating this stuff, that never accomplished anything,” Troake said. “It will be interesting to see now if this is the final end, to see what kind of a stand that Ottawa takes on our behalf, which I’m pretty well sure won’t be very harsh.” A spokesman for federal Fisheries Minister Loyola Hearn said the minister was in transit and unavailable for comment. “European politicians are doing for Canadians what our own politicians will not — that is, listen to the majority opposition to this cruel, unsustainable and unnecessary hunt,” said Sheryl Fink, an Ontario-based researcher with the International Fund for Animal Welfare. Animal rights activists have called for the end to Canada’s commercial seal hunt, the largest marine mammal slaughter in the world, for several decades. Seal hunters in Atlantic Canada say the hunt is humane, sustainable and an important part of their annual income, particularly in remote coastal communities where there is little else to do in the winter. “We do it because it’s part of our culture and we try to survive on this rock,” Troake said. The ban, if passed, would shut down critical shipment points for the sealing industry, including Holland and Germany. The seal hunt’s roots run deep in Newfoundland and Labrador, where the seal was once second only to cod as the most economically valuable species.
EU proposes import ban on seal products to protest inhumane huntBy CONSTANT BRAND | Associated Press Writer BRUSSELS, Belgium (AP) _ The European Union proposed an import ban Wednesday on products derived from seals that are killed in a cruel way, a move that could hurt the annual seal hunt in Canada — the largest in the world. Animal rights groups and lawmakers have called for an EU crackdown against seal hunts worldwide, prompting wrangling at EU headquarters over how far the European Commission should go. The plan announced Wednesday covers hunts worldwide, but especially focuses on Canada because of claims by anti-hunt campaigners that it is the cruelest. Canadian seal hunters use spiked clubs and rifles to kill seals. "Seal products coming from countries which practice cruel hunting methods must not be allowed to enter the EU," EU environmental commissioner Stavros Dimas told reporters. "The EU is committed to upholding high standards of animal welfare." Canada has threatened to take trade action against the EU if it imposes a ban, claiming a ban would decimate isolated east coast communities that are heavily dependent on the annual hunt. The EU proposals says the trade in seal products would be allowed from countries that can offer guarantees their hunting techniques are "consistent with high animal-welfare standards" are used and the animals are killed swiftly without undue suffering. Special exemptions will also be allowed for Canada's Arctic Inuit community. The ban recommends a certificate and labels be provided by countries exporting seal products making clear seal products they trade meet strict EU conditions. A ban would need the backing of the EU's 27 governments and the European Parliament before it could take effect. Canada's East Coast seal hunt is the largest of its kind in the world, with an average annual kill of about 300,000 harp seals. The Canadian slaughter of some 335,000 seals in 2006 brought in around $25 million. Several EU nations also conduct seal hunts, including Finland, Sweden and Britain. The largest markets are in Norway, China and Russia, however one-third of the trade in seal pelts, meat, and oils passes through the EU market, Dimas said.
New EU Rules On Seal Fur Trade12:19pm UK, Wednesday July 23, 2008 A leading animal welfare group fears new European measures to manage the seal fur trade will not go far enough. The European Commission has announced a ban on the sale of seal fur obtained using means that cause unnecessary suffering to the animal. The new proposals are thought to endorse techniques where the animal is unconscious or adequately stunned before it is killed. Sky News correspondent Ian Woods, who visited a seal hunt in Canada, said: "The devil is in the detail. The EU Commissioner for environment is saying that they will ban all seal products but if hunters or governments can prove that their hunt is carried out in humane conditions and that the animals themselves do not suffer, then they will allow the products into the country.
"A quarter of a million seals are killed each year - it is impossible check each kill. There is absolutely no way of checking it is carried out. "What they have introduced effectively is a partial ban which the Canadian government will try to exploit." Rosa Argent, of the International Fund for Animal Welfare, told Sky News Online: "Under a commercial hunt there's no humane way of killing." The European ruling is likely to have the greatest impact in Canada - the world’s largest exporter of seal fur. Canadian hunters are currently allowed to kill 275,000 each year from the country's existing six million seal population, but tighter European legislation could hit the trade. In 1983, the European Union outlawed trade in products from highly sought-after white-furred newborn harp seals, resulting in an increase in the hunting of older seal pups. Sir Paul McCartney published an appeal in January saying: "A European Union ban on all seal product trade would force nations where seal hunting has taken place to invest in real alternatives - jobs that will provide safe and sustainable futures." Sky News visited Canada in March to report on the start of the hunting season.
Canada rejects Brussels ban on its seal skinsby Staff Writers Canada's prime minister on Thursday warned the European Commission president not to prohibit Canadian seal skins, arguing that public pressure for a ban is based on misinformation from activists.
Prime Minister Stephen Harper told European Commission President Jose Manuel Barroso, according to a statement, "that it is imperative for European Union member nations to consider their next steps carefully as they discuss any measure that would restrict or exclude the sale of seal products within their borders." The two leaders met on the sidelines of a G8 summit in Japan. Harper said Canada's hunt is "humane, sustainable and regulated," and added "public pressure within the European Union to curb the sale of seal products is based on misinformation from anti-sealing organizations and extremist groups." Each year, anti-sealing activists clash with sealers and Canadian fisheries officials on Canada's Atlantic coast, denouncing the hunt as cruel. Protestors have called for a complete halt to all trade in seal furs, but World Trade Organization rules would make such a step impossible, a European source said. The commission is expected to make a decision whether to ban the importation of furs made from the skins of young seals hunted in Canada when it meets on July 23. It will then look to the EU's 27 member states to approve or vote down the measure. But Harper warned: "Canada will not stand by and accept measures that fly in the face of accepted international practices for sustainability and trade and undermine trade of seal products harvested in accordance with international standards."
Europe to ban seal products15.04.2008 - 19:08 CET | By Leigh Phillips After weeks of speculation, Europe is to propose a ban on seal products that result from animal cruelty, the EU's environment commissioner has said. "We will propose a ban of seal fur imports if (a country) can't prove they were obtained in a humane way," Stavros Dimas told the Reuters news agency on Saturday (12 April) at an informal meeting of EU environment ministers in Brdo, Slovenia. The commission's environment spokesperson confirmed to the EUobserver the commissioner's intentions. The ban would apply not just to seal pelts but all goods derived from seals, including meat, vitamins and other products. In recent weeks, articles have appeared in the press suggesting that the EU was considering a seal product ban, but until now, Brussels has strongly denied that a ban was to be imposed, stressing that such a move was only one of a number of possible actions Europe could take. Mr Dimas did not give a timetable for the introduction of such a proposal, saying only: "It will take some time." "I'm very much concerned at the way the hunt is conducted," he said, referring to a report from the European Food Safety Authority published last December, which concluded: "Many seals can be, and are, killed rapidly and effectively. (But) it is not always carried out effectively and this will lead to seals feeling the skinning." EU member states Belgium and the Netherlands introduced similar bans last year, prompting Canada, where some 275,000 harp seals are killed every year during the annual hunting season, to launch a trade dispute with the EU as a whole. Meanwhile, one of the leading international campaigners against the seal hunt, Paul Watson of the Sea Shepherd Conservation Society, whose vessel was seized on Saturday (12 April) by an elite marine squad from the Royal Canadian Mounted Police while monitoring the hunt, claimed that his team has captured footage of seals screaming while being skinned alive – evidence he says will be used to help convince European institutions to ban seal products. "We haven't seen any evidence of a humane hunt here," Mr Watson said. "We're presenting this evidence to the European Parliament. They are going to pass a bill to ban seal products. That will end the Canadian seal hunt." Two weeks ago, a delegation from Canada including an Inuit leader, fishermen from Newfoundland and Quebec and other regional officials visited Brussels in an attempt to convince Europe not to ban seal products. They said the hunt was at least as humane as any other form of hunting, and that it was not only a part of the Inuit lifestyle traditionally but to this day, the indigenous population depends on the hunt for meat and their livelihood. Commissioner Dimas said that he would make sure that the ban would not affect the traditional Inuit hunt. At the time of the visit, the officials handed out a transcript of a recent report on the Canadian Broadcasting Corporation radio, the Canadian public broadcaster, that had uncovered an interview from the late 1970s of Mr Watson, in which he talked about how easy it is to raise money on the back of the seal hunt. "Of all the animals in the world or any environmental problem in the world, the harp seal is the easiest issue to raise funds on," said Mr Watson. "They're beautiful and because of that, coupled with the horror of a sealer hitting them over the head with a club, it's an image that just goes right to the heart of animal lovers," he continued.
Sealers appeal to EU not to ban seal productsCONSTANT BRAND The Associated Press April 2, 2008 at 10:37 AM EDT BRUSSELS — Canadian sealers and politicians appealed Wednesday to the European Union not to ban the sale of products derived from seals. The appeal comes amid renewed charges that Canada's annual seal hunt off its eastern and northern coast lines is cruel and inhumane. The EU Environment Commissioner Stavros Dimas is considering a ban on all seal products amid increased pressure on him to take action by animal rights groups this year.
EU officials say he is expected to make his recommendations before summer. Special Ambassador Loyola Sullivan, who was leading a week-long Canadian trip to lobby officials in several European capitals, said a ban could violate world trade rules. And Mr. Sullivan is hinting at possible retaliatory trade action by Canada in response to any ban on seal products such as blubber, meat or pelts. “I believe strongly that there shouldn't be restrictions on access to markets,” Mr. Sullivan told reporters. “The European Commission has an obligation to live up to their [trade] commitments. We hope they exercise that right.” The Canadian government takes threats of a ban “very seriously” and will defend “the legitimate sustainable, humane, economic activity for some of the most disadvantaged people in our country,” he said. The controversial hunt resurfaced at the European Parliament and EU headquarters as this year's hunt began last week in the Gulf of St. Lawrence – the first stage in the largest such hunt in the world. Similar hunts also are carried out in Greenland, Norway, Russia, Namibia and EU-member Finland, but none has been scrutinized by European activists as much as Canada's. That inconsistency has frustrated Canadian officials. The European Parliament called last year on the EU to ban the import of seal fur. This year's hunt will be conducted under new rules intended to appease European concerns, with extra steps added to make sure the animals are dead before they are skinned – a recommendation made in an EU report released in December. That report was inconclusive on recommending a full EU ban. Canadian authorities have set this year's total allowable catch at 275,000 seals, up from 270,000 last year. Seventy per cent of the seals will be taken in an area off Newfoundland's north coast known as the Front, while 30 per cent will be taken in the Gulf of St. Lawrence – the first stage of the hunt. Nunavut Premier Paul Okalik said a ban would damage already fragile isolated communities that depend on the annual hunt for income and food. He also urged the 27-country EU not to apply a double standard on the hunt, citing examples of how animals are poorly treated and used after slaughter in Europe. “I'm sometimes troubled by some countries that try to pretend that our harvest is somehow unacceptable,” Mr. Okalik said. “At least in our case we are trying to use every part of the animal. ... Please look in the mirror and see what you are doing yourselves.” Denis Longuepie and Mark Small, who hunt for seals off the coasts of Quebec and Newfoundland and Labrador, said the way they kill seals with high-powered rifles as opposed to hakapiks – heavy clubs – is humane. “We are very professional, we take courses, we do what we have to do,” said Mr. Longuepie, from Îles-de-la-Madeleine, Que. Mr. Sullivan said Canada is seemingly fighting an uphill media war against campaigns by animal-welfare groups that often try to sway public opinion on the issue by showing photographs or film footage of cute and cuddly seal pups, and of dead and bloodied seals on ice flows. “We continue to see ... images of white-coat seals (the killing of which has) been illegal since 1987,” he said. “They sensationalize, they take steps beyond manipulation.” Environmental and animal-rights groups have already slammed Canadian officials for not allowing them better access to this year's start of the hunt. They insist the mass kill is devastating the harp seal population.
EU officials considering 'measures' to protest Canadian seal-huntThe Associated Press BRUSSELS, Belgium: The European Union is considering measures against Canada to protest its annual seal hunt set to start later this week off its Atlantic coast, EU officials said Wednesday. EU Environment Commissioner Stavros Dimas is "looking into the nature of the inhumane killing of seals," and is drafting a text to be presented before June, EU spokeswoman Barbara Helfferich told reporters. She would not say if the measures could include an import ban on products derived from Canadian seals, or other economic or political sanctions. Animal rights campaigners and lawmakers are putting increasing pressure on the EU's executive office to take a tougher stand against the annual hunt, which has been criticized as cruel. Seal hunts also are carried out in Greenland, Norway, Russia, Namibia and EU-member Finland, but none has been scrutinized by European activists as much as Canada's — which has frustrated Canadian officials. Animal rights groups often try to sway European opinion on the issue by showing photographs or film footage of cute and cuddly seal pups, and of dead and bloodied seals on ice flows. British EU lawmaker Neil Parish appealed to the Commission to impose a van on seal fur imports from Canada. "As the culling season gets under way, the time has come for the Commission to take action," said Parish, who chairs a European Parliament animal welfare panel. "The slaughter of seals in Canada, including seals that are just a few weeks old, is barbaric and the EU should not condone it. The methods used, cudgeling with a 'hakapik' or shooting, have too often not killed the seal outright, and I am not satisfied with Canadian assertions that seals are not still being skinned alive." The European Parliament last year called on the EU to impose a fur import ban. However, this year's Canadian hunt will be conducted under new rules meant to appease European concerns, with extra steps added to make sure the animals are dead before they are skinned — a recommendation made in an EU report released in December. That report was inconclusive on recommending a full EU ban. Canadian authorities have set this year's total allowable catch at 275,000 seals, up from 270,000 last year. Seventy percent of the seals will be taken in an area off Newfoundland's north coast known as the Front, while 30 percent will be taken in the Gulf of St. Lawrence — the first stage of the hunt. The EU already has in place a 1983 ban on the import of white pelts taken from baby seals, and a total ban could spell disaster for Canadian hunters and aboriginal peoples. Several EU nations, such as the Netherlands and Belgium, already have their own bans on all seal products. The United States has banned Canadian seal products since 1972. Animal rights groups say Canada's seal hunt is difficult to monitor, ravages the seal population and does not provide a lot of money for sealers. But sealers and the Canadian government have defended the hunt as sustainable, humane, well-managed and a necessary source of income for hunters. Many of them live in isolated fishing communities and deeply rely on the seal hunt because their cod fishing died out years ago. The slaughter of some 335,000 seals in 2006 brought about US$25 million. |
||||||||||||
(c) Harpseals.org 2000-2013 All rights reserved |